Bug Report - Catastrophic Failure in Video Generation Object Constancy & Keyframe Adherence
Product: Adobe Firefly (Image to Video Generation)Summary: The Adobe Firefly video generation AI is fundamentally incapable of creating a simple, mechanical animation of a recliner footrest opening, even when provided with explicit start and end keyframe images. After nearly 20 systematic and increasingly restrictive prompt variations, the AI consistently ignores user-provided keyframes and direct text commands, resulting in chaotic, nonsensical animations that break object constancy. This indicates a critical flaw where the AI's internal creative bias overrides all user input and visual data.Problem Description: The goal was to create a simple, 5-second product demonstration video showing a recliner's footrest moving from a closed position to an open position. Both the start and end images were provided as keyframes for the AI to work between.Over the course of 19+ attempts, we tried the following strategies, all of which failed:Simple Prompts: Basic descriptions o