"My questions are... 1) what color setting should I be using going foward to avoid this issue? That depends on where your file is going ( i.e., internet or print ). When you Export > JPG and there is no assigned profile, then whatever app that opens the JPG will ( or should ) ask what profile would you like to assign to it ( like opening in Photoshop ). But, getting back to your question. I have pretty good luck with both internet and print using a working RGB as Adobe RGB and working CMYK = SWOP Coated US Sheetfed v2. In rare cases, I may assign an sRGB to a RGB file destined for the internet. Very few browsers use color management and or honor color profiles., 2) is there any way to export the artwork faithfully with the colors I picked originally, without changing my color profile? When you have your Color Settings established and you have enabled color management, then upon Export your RGB will honor your Color Settings ( so, your Adobe RGB will go onto, upon opening, Photoshop will ask if you would you like to honor the Adobe RGB profile or assign a different one? You would keep Adobe RGB and the file should open and render as it did in your original Illustrator document ). By the way, your Color Settings should both be the same in Illustrator and Photoshop, in sync, sort of. I get very little shift when converting from Adobe RGB to my CMYK setting, which is ideal., I'm not sure how to get back to my original non-saturated colors when in the new profile. You mean using something other than Emulate Illustrator 6? You could take color readings from the Illustrator file that is not saturated ( i.e., write down specific RGB numbers for each color used ). Create a new document using your new color settings and copy and paste the file elements from the non saturated Emulate Illustrator 6 document. If you see a shift, then apply the previous RGB numbers to your colors and see if that matches.
... View more